Conferences

Futures and Pasts of Illiberal Constitutionalism – East Central Europe in Context

Futures & Pasts of Illiberal Constitutionalism

Futures & Pasts of Illiberal Constitutionalism

Image: Il-Liberal Project

Date: 12-13 September 2024
Venue: Central European University (CEU), Vienna

conference programmepdf, 172 kb

The “Towards Illiberal Constitutionalism in East Central Europe: Historical Analysis in Comparative and Transnational Perspectives” research project studies the rise of authoritarian governments in East Central Europe and far right and populist movements across Europe that has sparked concern that the liberal democratic order established after 1989 is falling apart. We set out to explore these complex phenomena in their historic and transnational contexts from multiple disciplinary perspectives. A central piece of our joint intellectual undertaking is a co-authored book written by the project team for a general audience (to be translated into German, Hungarian and Polish).

The book aims to present the origins, manifestations and alternatives of illiberal constitutionalism in East Central Europe in an informed, critical and approachable manner. It will first present alternative chronologies of liberalism and illiberalism, before turning to its diverse driving forces and inspirations (such as the far right, Christianity, various professions and social actors). The discussion will then focus on institutional practices including at the sites of the rule of law and the politics of rights, constitutional reform and the supranational European realm. Chapters will outline key debates on each theme, providing reference points for informed further engagement. For its authors the book is a genuine scholarly experiment of inter-disciplinary exploration and co-creation. For its audience it is meant to be a source of refreshing insight and intellectual inspiration. We aim to present an approachable narrative based on our key findings in a single voice, without turning to oversimplification or drowning the reader in nuance (of footnotes).

This conference is devoted to discussing key ideas and claims of this volume with experts across a wide range of fields and disciplines. We request each participant to join a panel discussion moderated by the lead authors of pertinent thematic chapters. These panel discussions are meant to inform, shape and situate the argument of the book.

Law, power, pluralisms. Revisiting Stanisław Ehrlich

Law, Power, Pluralism conference poster

Law, Power, Pluralism conference poster

Image: University of Warsaw

Prawo, władza, pluralizmy. Myśląc ze Stanisławem Ehrlichem

Date: 16-17 October 2023
Organizers: Faculty of Sociology, University of Warsaw; Faculty of Law and Administration, University of Warsaw; Polish Sociological Association’s Section of Sociology of Law
Venue: Institute for Applied Linguistics, University of Warsaw


Across the world, issues of law, legality, and legitimacy have recently emerged as increasingly important foci of democratic debates and political confrontations. The urgency of polemics over differing interpretations of the rule of law, constitutionalism, and checks and balances is not conducive to a deeper reflection on the power of law, its contested meaning, and diverse workings for various groups within society. Both historical perspective and critical concepts are needed in order to break the deadlock and refresh our thinking beyond the immediacy of handy cliches.
In this spirit, we propose to revisit and engage with the legacy of Stanisław Ehrlich (1907–1997), a leading legal scholar as well as one of the founders of the sociology of politics and political science in post-war Poland. His oeuvre, spanning over several decades, covered such themes as a critique of legal positivism, challenging the prevailing understanding of socialist legality, interest groups, pluralism, theory of norms and normative utterances, and decision-making processes, among others. In the spirit of interdisciplinarity, we invite contributions by sociologists, lawyers, historians, political scientists, feminist scholars, philosophers, and representatives of other social sciences. We invite both papers devoted to different aspects of Ehrlich’s thought and to different facets of our contemporary predicament read through the lenses of other critical theories. Focus on Ehrlich and his writings is not mandatory, though priority will be given to proposals that will, to a lesser or greater degree, engage with his oeuvre.
Ehrlich believed that every political system can and must be pluralistic because of the inherent diversity of underlying interests. Despite numerous negative developments, including the worldwide consolidation of anti-democratic forces in the last decade, this idea still offers hope for curbing authoritarianism. It also invites exploration of the consequences of Ehrlich’s thinking in both political and legal spheres. With this in mind, the conference invites contributions examining the manifestations of, opportunities for, and threats to all forms of pluralism in public life.

Precarious Constitutionalism – The Ambiguities of Liberal Orders and the Rise of Illiberalism in Central Europe and Latin America

Precarious Constiutionalism

Precarious Constiutionalism

Graphic: Il-Liberal Project

Date: 12-13 October 2023
Venue: Vila Lanna, Czech Academy of Sciences, Prague

conference programmepdf, 3 mb

Latin America and Central Europe are regions that share the experience of dictatorships, authoritarianism, strong modernizing states, rebellious civil societies and transitions to and from democracy.  Both regions were also part of the so-called third wave of democratization, which represented a time of hope for democracy and constitutionalism as a means of overcoming dictatorship and difficult history. Yet this period of democratizing constitutionalism, often through transplantations and adaptions from other constitutional models found elsewhere in the world, took place during the global rise of neoliberal economics and the Washington consensus with new political orders designed to increase the role of the market in the economy. The constitutional orders in these regions have undergone many upheavals in recent years, and the mob attack on the seats of the central constitutional institutions in Brazil in January this year is just one striking example.  

In both regions, the promises regarding economic, social, and cultural rights as well as participative and deliberative democratic models collided with economic models and political agendas placing their bets on the market as the key driver of growth and redistribution. Both regions have also experienced the return of right-wing politics in the last decade or more, accompanied in many cases by the rise of illiberal constitutionalism. But there are also crucial differences: the role and ambition of the so-called ’social constitutionalism‘ thriving in Latin America whereas almost non-existent in Central Europe

The conference seeks to explore these histories, while rejecting a black-and-white dichotomous perspective that portrays countries simply divided between liberal democrats and illiberal anti-democrats. In contrast we encourage papers that examine how the rise of illiberal concepts and practices emerged from the ambiguities of  liberal orders including the interlinkages of liberal economic reform programs with illiberal political practices and the non-democratic features inherent in liberal constitutional systems.

Dark Legacies of Illiberalism conference poster

Dark Legacies of Illiberalism conference poster

Image: University of Warsaw

Revisiting the Dark Legacies of Illiberalism: Varieties of Constitutionalism and Legal-Political Practices in Post-Authoritarian Europe

Date: 2-3 December 2022 
Venue: Rosensäle at Friedrich Schiller University Fürstengraben 27 | 07743 Jena

full programmepdf, 194 kb

conference reportExternal link

video recording keynote of Christian Jorges under 
Output/ Audio & Video

Until recently, the model of “constitutional tolerance” that allowed for a plurality of constitutional traditions within EU was understood as a strength. Not anymore. The constitutional transformation of Hungary and Poland towards authoritarian regimes in recent years has undermined the belief that despite the plurality there is a constitutional core shared by all member states allowing for mediation of conflicts and preserving the basic shared principles and values of EU as liberal democratic community. Today this diversity of constitutional orders is seen rather as a possible existential threat to both the EU and liberal democracy in Europe.

This conference aims to rethink the so-called ‘dark legacies’ of past illiberal legal systems in Europe and their implications for the present day.

The conference is a part of the VW-Stiftung funded project “Towards Illiberal Constitutionalism in East Central Europe: Historical Analysis in Comparative and Transnational Frame/Perspective” This project aims to enhance historical, interdisciplinary, and comparative perspectives in scholarly engagement with illiberal and authoritarian challenges to constitutional democracy in ECE situating the present-day conflicts in the longer history of the ebb and flow of constitutionalism, democracy, legality and pluralism in the region. Focusing primarily on the era of late state socialism, post-communist liberal transformation, into the current illiberal challenge to constitutional democracy, the project situates these regional developments within broader European and global transnational perspectives.